Ratings | The Reviews | FAQs



Q: Where do I find these titles if I want to buy them?
If you live in a city with a large Chinese population, your best bet is to look for a video rental store in the Chinese neighborhood. Otherwise, try www.rarekungfumovies.com (great old school collection for sale, and informative web site) and www.yesasia.com. Also check out the web sites for Tai Seng and World Video.

Q: Why don't you do lists of favorites? Why don't you do top tens, top fives, etc.?
A: I don't make a practice of list making for a number of reasons. These films have to be appreciated one at a time, and judged one at a time. More importantly, compiling lists is tricky. It all depends on what you're looking for. Some of the greatest fight scenes are contained in otherwise bad films. Some of the finest movies from a cinematic standpoint might have average or no fight choreography. Some of the best fight scenes ever shot constitute ten minutes of a film---but the rest of the movie doesn't hold up (so is it a great film?) Then you get into what constitutes great fight choreography. Hands? Kicks? Weapons? Can you compare modern action films with costume historical epics? And how do you compare old classic Bruce Lee films with much bigger-budget, modern productions starring Jet Li? How can you compare comedies with serious dramas? Or fantasies with horror films? (Yes, these are all sub-genres.) So, chances are, I won't stoop to list making.

Q: Why don't you have all of the ratings listed on the table of contents, so I can skip directly to the "5"s and not have to read the reviews?
A: That would be cheating. Again, going one film at a time respects the work of the film makers, and its players.

Q: What is your take on television series?
The sad news is, classic Chinese martial arts cinema has steadily dwindled over the last decade (the few bursts of activity, such as "Crouching Tiger", "Hero", etc.), to the point that there is not much going on, on a year by year basis. However, Chinese (Hong Kong, Taiwanese, Chinese) television has been long been bursting with quality martial arts productions and mini-series (historical as well as modern), including series featuring the best film fighters (Donnie Yen, Zhou Wen Zhou/Chiu Man Cheuk, Fan Siu Wong, Sammo Hung, etc.) and film-TV crossover stars. Hong Kong's TVB and ATV have produced many great martial arts mini-series, and their own stables of heroes and stars. Television has been the ideal choice for the epic stories of Jin Yong, Ku Long, and other historical martial arts novelists. Check out www.yesasia.com as well as www.spcnet.tv. The martial arts television is a separate universe deserves its own analysis, too much to tackle here at MAGTHKF.


Ratings | The Reviews | FAQs


Designed by Ron Lim | Reviews written by Passenger 58